Printify vs Printful
Printify and Printful both offer print-on-demand services, allowing businesses to sell custom products online without holding inventory. Printify provides access to a broad network of print providers, offering potentially more product variety and competitive pricing options. Printful utilizes its own facilities or closely managed partners, aiming for greater consistency in quality and fulfillment, though potentially with fewer product choices or higher base costs.
At Gralio.ai we help to simplify your decision-making process by offering detailed, side-by-side software comparisons like this one, to help you confidently choose the tool that aligns with your business goals.
This comparison was created by analysing 232 reviews and 60 websites, saving 1 hour, 47 minutes of reading.
About
About
Summary
Summary
Relative strengths of Printify (compared to Printful)
-
*Wider Network and Product Variety*: Printify connects users to a large, diverse network of print providers globally, often resulting in a broader selection of products and potentially more niche items compared to Printful's more curated catalog.
-
*Provider Choice and Potential Cost Savings*: By allowing users to choose from different print providers within its network, Printify enables businesses to compare prices, production times, and locations, potentially finding more cost-effective options for specific products or shipping destinations.
-
*Structured Pricing Tiers*: Printify offers clear Free and Premium subscription tiers, with the Premium plan providing significant product discounts (up to 20%), which can offer better value for businesses with sufficient volume compared to Printful's less defined pricing structure (though Printful offers volume discounts too).
Relative weaknesses of Printify (compared to Printful)
-
*Variability in Quality and Fulfillment*: Because Printify relies on a network of independent printers, the quality of the final product, printing consistency, and fulfillment speed can vary significantly between providers, potentially leading to unpredictable customer experiences.
-
*Potentially More Complex Issue Resolution*: When problems arise (e.g., print errors, shipping delays), resolving them can sometimes involve communication between the seller, Printify, and the specific print provider, which can be more complex and potentially slower than dealing with Printful's more centralized support and production.
-
*Product Availability and Consistency*: Dependence on multiple independent suppliers means products can be discontinued, go out of stock, or change without much notice, forcing sellers to find replacements or update listings more frequently than might be necessary with Printful's more controlled inventory approach.
Who should use Printify VS. Printful
Who should use Printify VS. Printful
Printify seems like a solid choice for online stores wanting to offer custom print-on-demand items without handling inventory or printing themselves. We find it's particularly handy for those on platforms like Etsy or Shopify. Users appreciate the wide product selection and ease of getting started, making it accessible even for newer businesses looking to expand their offerings quickly.
Printful is a popular choice for businesses venturing into print-on-demand. We see it work well for online stores, especially those just starting or looking to scale without holding inventory. Users often praise its smooth integration with platforms like Shopify and Etsy, and the automated order handling is a big plus. While it offers a good range of products, keep an eye on potential inconsistencies in print quality and shipping times that some users have mentioned. Overall, it's a solid tool for e-commerce entrepreneurs looking to easily sell custom products online under their own brand name without managing stock or logistics themselves.
-
In our experience, Printify works best for small to medium-sized businesses (1-1000 employees) wanting straightforward print-on-demand.
-
We see Printify primarily used by E-commerce businesses looking to easily add custom-designed products to their online storefronts.
-
We find Printful works best for small to medium-sized businesses, typically those with 1 to 1000 employees needing scalable fulfillment.
-
In our experience, Printful is particularly strong for companies operating directly in the E-commerce space, selling custom goods online.
Printify and Printful features
Supported Partially supported Not supported Type in the name of the feature or in your own words tell us what you need
Printify and Printful features
- Higher profit marginsSupported
Printify supports higher profit margins via low upfront costs, competitive pricing, and premium discounts.
SupportedPrintful allows for potentially higher profit margins through flexible pricing and competitive base costs.
- Quality ProductsPartially supported
Printify offers potentially high-quality products, but consistency varies across providers. The 10K 5-star review claim isn't verified.
SupportedPrintful receives a 4.6/5 rating from over 67,805 reviews, indicating generally positive feedback on product quality.
- Immediate ProductionNot supported
Printify automates order processing, but production takes 2-7 business days.
SupportedPrintful starts production immediately after the order is placed, typically taking 2-5 business days to fulfill.
- Label printingSupported
Printify supports printing shipping labels through its integrated shipping solutions.
Not supportedShipping label printing is not directly supported.
- Squarespace integrationNot supported
Orders are automatically fulfilled by Printify, not imported.
SupportedPrintful receives orders automatically when they are placed through Squarespace.
- Shopping linksSupported
Printify supports linking online stores for automated order fulfillment.
Not supportedPrintful does not directly support adding shopping links to publications.
Qualities
Qualities
- Value and Pricing Transparency-1Strongly negative sentiment-0.56Rather negative sentiment
- Customer Service+0.5Rather positive sentiment+0Neutral sentiment
- Ease of Use+0.74Strongly positive sentiment+1Strongly positive sentiment
- Reliability and Performance+0Neutral sentiment+0.27Neutral sentiment
- Ease of Implementation+0.2Neutral sentiment+0.87Strongly positive sentiment
Printify and Printful Pricing
User sentiment
See full Pricing page
User sentiment
Printify and Printful review insights
145 reviews analysed from and
Printify and Printful review insights
Users love
- Wide selection of products and printing companies to choose from.
- User-friendly interface that makes designing and listing products easy.
- Seamless integration with popular ecommerce platforms like Etsy and Shopify.
- No upfront inventory costs, making it accessible for new businesses.
- Helpful customer support that is responsive and generally resolves issues effectively.
- Seamless integration with various e-commerce platforms (Etsy, Shopify, etc.).
- Automated order fulfillment and no inventory management required.
- User-friendly design interface with mockup generator.
- Wide selection of customizable products (apparel, accessories, etc.).
- Helpful and responsive customer support.
Users dislike
- Inconsistent product availability leading to discontinued items and supplier changes, requiring relisting products.
- Customer service can be slow and unhelpful, with inconsistent responses and difficulties obtaining refunds.
- Occasional technical glitches and issues with order processing, particularly during peak seasons.
- Shipping costs can be high and vary significantly between suppliers and regions.
- Limited control over shipping options and packaging customization.
- Inconsistent print and embroidery quality, requiring replacements and customer service interaction.
- Screen-printed items fade quickly after a few washes.
- Limited product variety compared to competitors.
- High shipping costs and slow delivery times, especially outside the US.
- Occasional stock shortages and difficulties managing out-of-stock items.
Printify and Printful Ratings
Printify and Printful Ratings
G23.8/5(13)
Glassdoor4.5/5(192)
- G23.6/5(66)
Capterra4.3/5(66)- Glassdoor3.7/5(205)
Company health
Company health
Employee growth
Web traffic
Financing
How do Printify's and Printful's product availability compare for consistent fulfillment?
Which platform, Printify or Printful, offers better control over shipping options and costs?
What are the advantages of Printify?
What are the disadvantages of Printify?
Alternatives to Printify and Printful
Michal has worked at startups for many years and writes about topics relating to software selection and IT management. As a former consultant for Bain, a business advisory company, he also knows how to understand needs of any business and find solutions to its problems.
Tymon is a seasoned CTO who loves finding the perfect tools for any task. He recently headed up the tech department at Batmaid, a well-known Swiss company, where he managed about 60 software purchases, including CX, HR, Payroll, Marketing automation and various developer tools.
How are we doing?
An AI tool that observes your work, finds inefficiencies, and suggests smarter ways to do things. Maybe you can use your tools better, automate tasks, or switch software.