Percent Pledge vs Benevity

by Gralio Feb 21, 2025

Percent Pledge and Benevity both offer CSR program management, but target different needs. Percent Pledge prioritizes simplicity and ease of use, while Benevity offers a broader feature set for larger organizations with more complex requirements.

At Gralio.ai we help to simplify your decision-making process by offering detailed, side-by-side software comparisons like this one, to help you confidently choose the tool that aligns with your business goals.

This comparison was created by analysing 335 reviews and 60 websites, saving 2 hours, 21 minutes of reading.

Percent Pledge

Website LinkedIn Twitter

Benevity

Website LinkedIn Twitter

About

Percent Pledge is a software platform designed to manage corporate social responsibility (CSR) programs. It enables employees to donate to charities, participate in matching programs, track volunteer hours, and find volunteering opportunities. The platform includes impact reporting tools and integrates with other HR and business systems. Percent Pledge prides itself on user-friendliness, quick implementation, and dedicated support from social impact experts.

Benevity is a software platform designed for businesses to manage their corporate social responsibility programs. It allows companies to organize employee volunteering efforts, manage donations (including matching programs), and handle grants to non-profit organizations. It offers tools to measure the impact of these initiatives and provides data reporting. Benevity aims to make it easier for companies to engage employees in social impact activities and demonstrate their commitment to social responsibility.

Summary

Main difference

Percent Pledge is better for smaller companies focused on ease of use and transparent pricing, offering strong customer support and quick setup. Benevity caters to larger enterprises with complex CSR needs, providing a wider range of features and integrations but potentially higher costs and less responsive support.

Relative strengths of Percent Pledge (compared to Benevity)

Easier implementation and better customer support, making it ideal for companies new to CSR programs.
More transparent pricing structure.
Stronger focus on user-friendliness, simplifying donation and volunteering management.

Relative weaknesses of Percent Pledge (compared to Benevity)

Less comprehensive features compared to Benevity, especially for grant management and complex matching programs.
Smaller network of non-profit organizations.
Limited integrations with other business systems.

What companies are using Percent Pledge and Benevity?

No data

Who should use Percent Pledge VS. Benevity

Percent Pledge is a CSR platform streamlining employee donations, matching programs, volunteering, and impact reporting. Users praise its ease of use and comprehensive charity database but note some limitations with volunteer search filters and integrations. Perfect for mid-sized companies focused on impactful social engagement, Percent Pledge simplifies giving and volunteering.

Benevity is a CSR management platform that empowers businesses to organize employee volunteering, donations, and grants. Users praise its versatile data collection and facilitation of employee engagement in social impact activities. However, some users have reported delays in fund disbursement and difficulties with customer support. Best for companies looking to streamline their CSR programs but may not be suitable for those requiring quick fund disbursement or responsive customer service.

Best for medium-sized companies seeking to enhance their CSR programs.
Ideal for sectors like Manufacturing, Media, and Software, where social impact is key.

Best fit for small, medium, and enterprise businesses.
Ideal for Non-profit & Government, Healthcare, Finance, Retail, and other industries.

Percent Pledge and Benevity features

Supported

Partially supported

Not supported

Type in the name of the feature or in your own words tell us what you need

Access to Large Nonprofit Network

Supported

Percent Pledge offers access to over 2 million global charities.

Supported

Benevity provides access to almost two million vetted nonprofits globally and locally.
Donation Platform

Supported

Percent Pledge offers access to numerous charities, donation matching, and impact reporting.

Supported

Benevity provides a donation platform with access to charities, donation matching, campaign management, and real-time tracking.
Volunteering Platform

Supported

Percent Pledge offers a platform for finding volunteer opportunities, managing time off, and team building.

Supported

Benevity's platform enables employees to find volunteer opportunities, track hours, and participate in team-building activities.
Volunteer Event Management

Supported

Percent Pledge manages full-service volunteer events, including nonprofit partnerships and virtual/in-person events.

Partially supported

Benevity provides tools to manage events, but not full-service logistics.
Donation matching

Supported

Percent Pledge automates and simplifies donation matching for companies and their employees.

Supported

Benevity supports donation matching, including automated corporate matching and peer-to-peer matching.
Adding new charities

Not supported

Employees cannot add new charities.

Not supported

Employees cannot directly add new charities.

Qualities

Value and Pricing Transparency

+1

Strongly positive sentiment

-1

Strongly negative sentiment
Customer Service

+0.43

Rather positive sentiment

-1

Strongly negative sentiment
Ease of Use

+0.93

Strongly positive sentiment

+0

Neutral sentiment
Reliability and Performance

+0.5

Rather positive sentiment

-0.82

Strongly negative sentiment
Ease of Implementation

+1

Strongly positive sentiment

-1

Strongly negative sentiment
Scalability

No data

No data

Percent Pledge and Benevity Pricing

Percent Pledge offers three bundles: Platform Bundle, The Works Bundle, and Volunteer Bundle. All plans include features like donations and campaigns, volunteer event management, impact reporting, access to a global network of nonprofit partners, impact reports, and support from social impact managers.

See full Pricing page

Benevity's website doesn't directly disclose pricing information. It encourages visitors to request a demo for personalized pricing details.

User sentiment

Strongly negative

-1

See full Pricing page

Percent Pledge and Benevity review insights

315 reviews analysed from and

Users love

Easy to use and intuitive interface for donations and volunteering.
Comprehensive database of charities and volunteer opportunities.
Seamless company donation matching process.
Helpful dashboards and reporting tools.
Excellent customer support, responsive and helpful.

Versatile data collection and retention capabilities.
Facilitates employee engagement in corporate social responsibility initiatives.
Streamlines the process for managing grants and corporate contributions.
Offers various ways for employees to contribute, including donations and volunteering.
Provides a platform for companies to demonstrate their commitment to social impact.

Users dislike

Limited search filters for volunteer opportunities (e.g., single-day events).
Limited scope of available organizations.
Difficulty finding smaller organizations associated with larger nonprofits.
HRIS integrations are not native, requiring third-party tools.
Lack of confirmation for charity pledge receipt.
VolunteerMatch feature not always functional.
Lack of a mobile app.

Delays in disbursing funds, sometimes exceeding the promised ETA of two months.
Lack of transparency and communication regarding disbursement delays.
Difficulty contacting customer support and receiving timely responses.
Non-profit organizations reporting missing donations and lack of response from Benevity.
Confusing user interface for managing donations and tracking their status.

Percent Pledge and Benevity Ratings

G2

4.5/5

(57)
Capterra

4.8/5

(50)

G2

4.8/5

(172)
Capterra

3.3/5

(36)
TrustPilot

1.7/5

(20)
Glassdoor

3.5/5

(321)

Company health

Employee growth

No change in the last year

6% increase in the last year

Web traffic

6% increase in the last quarter

22% decrease in the last quarter

Financing

September 2023 - $3M

October 2020 - $69M

How do Percent Pledge's and Benevity's user experiences compare for employees?

Percent Pledge is praised for its easy-to-use interface and seamless donation matching process, contributing to a positive user experience. However, some users note limitations in search filters and available organizations. Benevity, while offering robust features, receives mixed reviews regarding user experience. Some users appreciate its versatility and comprehensive tools, while others report a confusing interface and difficulties managing donations. Benevity also faces criticism for delays in disbursing funds and poor customer support responsiveness, potentially negatively impacting the user experience.

Which platform offers better reporting tools for tracking CSR program impact?

While both platforms offer impact reporting, Benevity's tools are geared towards larger enterprises with more complex CSR programs, offering more robust data collection and reporting capabilities. Percent Pledge, while user-friendly, is better suited for smaller to mid-sized companies with less complex reporting needs. Therefore, Benevity offers better reporting tools for tracking CSR program impact, particularly for larger organizations.

What are the advantages of Percent Pledge?

Percent Pledge offers advantages in user-friendliness, ease of implementation, and dedicated support from social impact experts. Users praise its intuitive interface and seamless donation matching process. It's particularly well-suited for companies prioritizing ease of use and quick setup for their CSR programs.

What are the disadvantages of Percent Pledge?

Percent Pledge has some limitations regarding volunteer opportunity searches, lacking advanced filters for specific events like single-day opportunities. The platform's scope of available organizations might be limited, and users have reported difficulties finding smaller organizations associated with larger nonprofits. Additionally, HRIS integrations are not native, necessitating third-party tools, and some users have experienced issues with the VolunteerMatch feature and the absence of a mobile app.

Alternatives to Percent Pledge and Benevity

YourCause CSRconnect

YourCause CSRconnect is a software platform designed to help mid-sized companies manage and improve their corporate social responsibility programs. It offers tools for managing employee giving, volunteering, and corporate grant programs all in one place. With CSRconnect, you can streamline program administration, track your company's social impact, and make reporting easier. It also offers features to increase employee engagement like gamification and incentives, helping you build a culture of giving back in your company.

NetSuite

NetSuite is a popular cloud-based business management software for mid-sized and large companies. It brings together tools for managing finances, customer relationships (CRM), inventory, and online sales. With a focus on automation and data insights, NetSuite helps businesses streamline operations and make informed decisions. It's widely used across various industries, from manufacturing to services, promising better control and growth.

Millie

Millie is a software platform that helps businesses in the USA of all sizes create and manage employee volunteering programs. It aims to make giving back to the community easy and rewarding for employees while helping companies boost their social impact. Millie provides tools to organize volunteer events, track employee participation, and measure the overall impact of the program. It stands out by offering a user-friendly platform and resources designed specifically for businesses looking to engage in corporate social responsibility.

BambooHR

BambooHR is an HR software platform designed for small and medium-sized businesses. It brings together various HR functions like hiring, onboarding, payroll, benefits, and employee data management into one system. This allows for streamlined workflows, automated tasks, and easier access to employee information. BambooHR aims to simplify HR processes, improve data accuracy, and enhance the employee experience. It is used by companies in various industries and boasts features like custom reporting and integrations with other software.

Groundswell

Groundswell is a software platform designed for companies to manage their charitable giving and volunteering programs. It allows employees to donate to charities from their paycheck, receive company donation matches, and discover volunteering opportunities. Groundswell simplifies corporate social responsibility efforts with features like automated matching, donation gifting for employee milestones, and impact reporting. A key benefit is the quick distribution of funds, with donations often reaching charities within 24 hours.

ClickUp

ClickUp is a comprehensive work management platform designed to consolidate various work processes into one centralized location. It offers a wide array of features including task management, project planning, document collaboration, communication tools, goal setting, and automation options. ClickUp aims to enhance team collaboration, improve visibility across projects, and streamline workflows for increased productivity regardless of team size or industry.

Page co-authored by

Michal Kaczor

CEO at Gralio

Michal has worked at startups for many years and writes about topics relating to software selection and IT management. As a former consultant for Bain, a business advisory company, he also knows how to understand needs of any business and find solutions to its problems.

Tymon Terlikiewicz

CTO at Gralio

Tymon is a seasoned CTO who loves finding the perfect tools for any task. He recently headed up the tech department at Batmaid, a well-known Swiss company, where he managed about 60 software purchases, including CX, HR, Payroll, Marketing automation and various developer tools.

How are we doing?

Is this information helpful to you? Is there anything we are missing?

Did this help you select your product?

Other issues? Vote & Let us know