F5 NGINX vs HAProxy

by Gralio Feb 12, 2025

F5 NGINX and HAProxy are both robust tools for managing web traffic, but they cater to different needs. NGINX provides a comprehensive suite of integrated tools for web application delivery, security, and performance optimization. HAProxy, with its focus on load balancing, excels in high-performance scenarios requiring flexible configuration and efficient resource utilization.

At Gralio.ai we help to simplify your decision-making process by offering detailed, side-by-side software comparisons like this one, to help you confidently choose the tool that aligns with your business goals.

This comparison was created by analysing 325 reviews and 60 websites, saving 2 hours, 18 minutes of reading.

F5 NGINX

Website LinkedIn Twitter

HAProxy

Website LinkedIn Twitter

About

F5 NGINX is a suite of software tools designed to build and run high-performance websites and applications. It helps companies handle large volumes of online traffic, improve the speed and reliability of their websites and applications, and protect them from cyberattacks. F5 NGINX is used by many large companies, particularly in industries like technology and media, where handling high volumes of traffic is crucial.

HAProxy is a popular software tool that helps balance internet traffic to ensure websites and applications run smoothly and reliably, even with large numbers of users. Businesses use HAProxy to improve their online services by making them fast, secure, and always available.

Summary

Main difference

F5 NGINX offers a broader suite of integrated tools for web application delivery and security, including load balancing, WAF, and CDN, making it suitable for complex deployments. HAProxy focuses primarily on load balancing and excels in high-performance scenarios with its flexible configuration and efficient resource utilization, ideal for situations where load balancing is the primary concern.

Relative strengths of F5 NGINX (compared to HAProxy)

Stronger integration with WAF and CDN: NGINX offers tighter integration with web application firewall (WAF) and content delivery network (CDN) services, which simplifies deployment and management of security and performance features.
Comprehensive suite of tools: NGINX provides a wider range of tools for web application delivery beyond load balancing, including application server, API gateway, and security features, making it a more versatile solution.
Easier management with NGINX Controller: The NGINX Controller provides a centralized management interface for configuring and monitoring NGINX instances, simplifying administration and automation.

Relative weaknesses of F5 NGINX (compared to HAProxy)

Higher pricing: NGINX Plus, which includes advanced features and support, can be more expensive than HAProxy, particularly for smaller deployments.
Steeper learning curve: The broader feature set and configuration options of NGINX can make it more complex to learn and manage compared to HAProxy.
Resource intensive: NGINX can consume more resources compared to the lightweight HAProxy, potentially requiring more powerful hardware for optimal performance.

Who should use F5 NGINX VS. HAProxy

F5 NGINX is a powerful suite of tools for building and running high-performance web applications. It excels at handling large traffic volumes, boosting speed and reliability, and protecting against cyberattacks. Its HTTP/2 support and load balancing integration are key features. F5 NGINX is a popular choice for large companies in demanding industries like technology and media.

HAProxy is a versatile load balancing solution designed to optimize website and application performance and ensure high availability. Users praise its flexibility, automation capabilities, and stability, handling millions of requests per second. However, some find the debugging process challenging and the documentation for certain tools limited. It's ideal for businesses of all sizes seeking to improve their online services.

Best fit for small, medium, and large businesses.
Ideal for Software, IT, and Telecommunications companies.

Ideal for small, medium, and large enterprises seeking enhanced online service performance.
Suitable for businesses across various industries aiming to optimize website and application reliability.

F5 NGINX and HAProxy features

Supported

Partially supported

Not supported

Type in the name of the feature or in your own words tell us what you need

Load Balancing Integration

Supported

NGINX supports load balancing and integrates with other services.

Supported

HAProxy supports load balancing with various algorithms for traffic distribution.
API management

Supported

NGINX supports API management, design, and security through its API Management module and broader security solutions.

Partially supported

HAProxy can manage and secure APIs, but not design them.
Application protection

Supported

NGINX App Protect DoS protects against DDoS attacks.

Supported

HAProxy protects against DDoS attacks using features like rate limiting and access control lists.
Hybrid deployment

Supported

F5 NGINX supports hybrid deployments, connecting cloud and on-premise systems.

Supported

HAProxy supports hybrid deployments, connecting cloud and on-premise systems.
Performance monitoring

Supported

NGINX supports performance monitoring via NGINX One, Amplify, and Plus.

Partially supported

HAProxy offers basic performance metrics, but relies on external tools for website speed monitoring.
HTTP/2 Support

Supported

F5 NGINX supports HTTP/2 for efficient content delivery.

Supported

HAProxy supports HTTP/2 since version 1.8, with full support in versions 2.2 and later.

Qualities

Value and Pricing Transparency

No data

+0.29

Neutral sentiment
Customer Service

No data

+0.86

Strongly positive sentiment
Ease of Use

No data

+0.77

Strongly positive sentiment
Reliability and Performance

No data

+0.97

Strongly positive sentiment
Ease of Implementation

No data

+0.35

Rather positive sentiment
Scalability

No data

+0.85

Strongly positive sentiment

F5 NGINX and HAProxy Pricing

F5 NGINX offers various products like NGINX One, NGINX App Protect, and NGINX as a Service for Azure. These are available through annual enterprise subscriptions. Contact F5 sales for detailed pricing information. Several packaging options are available for NGINX One, including Per Instance and for Kubernetes. NGINX App Protect is offered as a standalone product or as part of NGINX One. NGINX as a Service for Azure is a pay-as-you-go service billed per consumption unit per hour.

See full Pricing page

Could not find a pricing page.

See full Pricing page

F5 NGINX and HAProxy review insights

325 reviews analysed from

Users love

High performance and speed, especially for static content and high concurrency.
Lightweight and low resource usage.
Open-source and free to use, with a large and active community.
Easy setup and configuration for basic use cases.
Versatile, acting as a web server, reverse proxy, load balancer, and cache.

Highly flexible configuration, from simple conditions to Lua scripting.
Easy integration with automation software like Ansible.
Well-maintained project with long support periods and in-place upgrades.
Very stable and reliable; used in production for years without downtime.
Excellent performance, handling millions of requests per second.

Users dislike

Difficult configuration for complex setups or advanced features.
Limited GUI functionality in the free version, requiring external tools or NGINX Plus.
Documentation can be lacking, especially for non-English speakers and advanced configurations.
Limited Windows support compared to Linux.

WAF feature is only available in the Enterprise Edition.
Limited documentation for tools like halog.
JSON logs are only supported in HAProxy 3+.
Difficult to debug; logs are not very clear.
Lacks native SSL termination and session persistence.

F5 NGINX and HAProxy Ratings

G2

4.6/5

(106)
Glassdoor

5.0/5

(1)

G2

4.6/5

(229)
Glassdoor

4.8/5

(5)

Company health

Employee growth

2% increase in the last year

12% increase in the last year

Web traffic

8% decrease in the last quarter

14% decrease in the last quarter

Financing

April 2009 - $25M

No data

How do NGINX and HAProxy compare in ease of implementation?

NGINX has no data available regarding ease of implementation. HAProxy scores a 0.35 out of 1.0 for ease of implementation, indicating it may present some challenges during setup and configuration. Therefore, based on available data, NGINX may be easier to implement. However, additional information is needed for a conclusive comparison.

Which product, NGINX or HAProxy, offers better integration with existing infrastructure?

HAProxy offers better integration with existing infrastructure due to its focus on hybrid deployments, explicitly connecting cloud and on-premise systems. While NGINX also offers load balancing integration, HAProxy's stated support for hybrid environments suggests a more seamless integration with diverse infrastructure setups.

What are the advantages of F5 NGINX?

F5 NGINX offers strong support for the software and IT industries, making it a good choice for technology-focused companies. It provides features like load balancing, HTTP/2 support, and performance monitoring, which are crucial for handling high traffic volumes and ensuring fast, reliable web applications.

What are the disadvantages of F5 NGINX?

NGINX, while powerful, can have a steeper learning curve for configuration and management compared to some alternatives. Users have reported difficulties in debugging due to less comprehensive logging. Some advanced features, like a web application firewall (WAF), may require a separate subscription or integration. Finally, while suitable for high-traffic environments, its complexity might be overkill for smaller deployments where simpler solutions could suffice.

Alternatives to F5 NGINX and HAProxy

Cloudflare Application Security and Performance

Cloudflare Application Security and Performance safeguards and optimizes your online applications and digital presence. It acts as a protective shield against cyberattacks, while simultaneously boosting speed and reliability for your users. This comprehensive platform consolidates various security and performance tools, simplifying your IT infrastructure. Cloudflare caters to a wide range of businesses, from small startups to large enterprises, seeking a unified solution for their online security and performance needs. It promises enhanced protection, faster loading times, and simplified IT management.

Akamai Network Operator

Akamai Network Operator is a suite of tools focusing on optimizing and securing network infrastructure for businesses. It provides services for managing traffic flow, boosting security, and improving the performance of websites and applications. This is achieved through a globally distributed network that helps deliver content faster and protect against cyberattacks. Akamai Network Operator is particularly beneficial for companies with high-traffic websites and online services where speed and security are critical.

Datadog

Datadog is a cloud-based software platform that gives you a complete view of your company's technology systems, from websites and apps to servers and databases. It helps you monitor performance, analyze data, and improve security, all in one place. Datadog is designed for companies of all sizes and is used by various teams, including IT, development, and security. It helps businesses ensure their technology runs smoothly, efficiently, and securely.

Ivanti vADC

Ivanti vADC is a software tool that makes websites and apps run faster and more reliably. It acts like a traffic manager, ensuring smooth access even when many users are online. This can be particularly beneficial for mid-sized companies in the US looking to improve their online presence and user experience.

StackPath

StackPath is a platform offering security and performance tools for websites and online applications. It helps businesses protect their online presence from cyberattacks and ensures fast loading times for users. Key features include content delivery, web application firewall, and protection against distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attacks. StackPath is designed for businesses of all sizes that prioritize online security and reliability.

Microsoft Defender for Cloud

Microsoft Defender for Cloud enhances the security of your cloud resources. It helps find and fix vulnerabilities, protect against cyber threats, and maintain compliance with security standards. It provides a range of security features covering applications, data, and infrastructure across multiple cloud platforms, not just Microsoft's. Defender for Cloud helps organizations of all sizes manage their cloud security posture more effectively.

Page co-authored by

Michal Kaczor

CEO at Gralio

Michal has worked at startups for many years and writes about topics relating to software selection and IT management. As a former consultant for Bain, a business advisory company, he also knows how to understand needs of any business and find solutions to its problems.

Tymon Terlikiewicz

CTO at Gralio

Tymon is a seasoned CTO who loves finding the perfect tools for any task. He recently headed up the tech department at Batmaid, a well-known Swiss company, where he managed about 60 software purchases, including CX, HR, Payroll, Marketing automation and various developer tools.

How are we doing?

Is this information helpful to you? Is there anything we are missing?

Did this help you select your product?

Other issues? Vote & Let us know